Predators' dive extends to five in late loss to Ducks
While they showed admirable pluck by fighting back on four different occasions to tie the game, the Nashville Predators ran out of gas against the Anaheim Ducks tonight, yielding a massive 17-3 shot differential in the 3rd period, and allowing a wide-open Paul Mara to score the winning goal for Anaheim with just 1.7 seconds left in regulation.
Follow after the jump for all the soul-crushing details...
The Preds return to Bridgestone Arena Saturday, November 13 vs. the Stanley Cup champion Chicago Blackhawks, so plan ahead and use the OtF discount to save money on Nashville Predators tickets for this, or any other home game.
First, the video highlights (viewer discretion advised)...
- Dare I mention that the power play went 0-for-4 in six minutes of action? I dare...
- Shane O'Brien's getting exposed a bit these days. He's best suited as a 3rd-pair and PK man, and is having difficulty against elite opponents. Get well soon, Ryan Suter!
- Colin Wilson had a really off night. He wasn't noticeable at all out there, and the numbers below bear that out.
- Anders Lindback was OK in a rare start. You can't particularly blame him on the goals that were given up, but he did look shaky on a couple occasions.
- The Sullivan-O'Reilly-Hornqvist line had a nice night, accounting for 3 of the 4 goals and getting many dangerous chances at other times. It was also great to see Sully cash in on a mini-breakaway.
- After that, however, the pickings were pretty slim. J.P. Dumont had some nice moments, and that was about it among the forwards.
- Well, Wade Belak almost got an assist during his 1:48 of action, but Dumont put his pass off the goalpost.
- It struck me during a late PK that the Preds really don't seem to be blocking many shots this year. Yup, 2nd-lowest total in the league so far.
- The losing streak now stands at five games, including a shutout on home ice, two blowouts, and two 3rd-period collapses. While folks would like to see some strong action taken, I'm not sure there are many good options available outside of waiting for Ryan Suter and Martin Erat to return. There's nobody in Milwaukee who would provide a significant upgrade over personnel already here, and making a trade under such circumstances is rarely the wise move.
As for the advanced even-strength stats...
| Even Strength | Individual Totals | Team Totals While Player Is On Ice | ||||||||||
| Player | Pos | EV TOI | Shots | Shts Blkd | Missed Shts | Blocks | SOG For | SOG Ag | SOG +/- | Tot SF | Tot SA | Corsi |
| David Legwand | C | 16:29 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 3 | 13 | -10 | 6 | 18 | -12 |
| Joel Ward | R | 15:47 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 5 | 13 | -8 | 13 | 17 | -4 |
| Marcel Goc | C | 15:30 | 2 | 1 | 2 | 0 | 7 | 11 | -4 | 18 | 16 | +2 |
| Jerred Smithson | R | 14:06 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 3 | 11 | -8 | 6 | 17 | -11 |
| Cal O'Reilly | C | 13:38 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 8 | 9 | -1 | 17 | 14 | +3 |
| Patric Hornqvist | R | 13:17 | 2 | 1 | 2 | 0 | 7 | 11 | -4 | 15 | 15 | 0 |
| Colin Wilson | C | 12:10 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 10 | -9 | 5 | 16 | -11 |
| Steve Sullivan | L | 11:57 | 3 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 8 | 9 | -1 | 16 | 13 | +3 |
| Jordin Tootoo | R | 9:52 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 3 | 2 | +1 | 8 | 5 | +3 |
| J-P Dumont | R | 9:42 | 0 | 1 | 2 | 0 | 7 | 2 | +5 | 14 | 4 | +10 |
| Nick Spaling | C | 8:15 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 3 | 4 | -1 | 5 | 7 | -2 |
| Wade Belak | R | 1:48 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 | +1 | 2 | 0 | +2 |
| Francis Bouillon | D | 21:15 | 1 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 8 | 15 | -7 | 19 | 19 | 0 |
| Shea Weber | D | 20:19 | 3 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 6 | 13 | -7 | 17 | 16 | +1 |
| Kevin Klein | D | 18:05 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 8 | 13 | -5 | 12 | 23 | -11 |
| Shane O'Brien | D | 15:33 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 6 | 12 | -6 | 11 | 21 | -10 |
| Alexander Sulzer | D | 11:43 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 5 | 7 | -2 | 13 | 11 | +2 |
| Cody Franson | D | 9:02 | 2 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 5 | 4 | +1 | 12 | 6 | +6 |
Be sure to "Like" our site on Facebook (now at www.facebook.com/OnTheForecheck)! To keep up with all of our coverage of the Nashville Predators, you can follow us on Twitter (@Forechecker, @predatweeter, @SLakePreds & @AdsRoundtable) and if you have any questions, feel free to email me at the.forechecker@gmail.com.
54 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
money
i wish the preds had some. the Red wings were able to help their u=injury problems last year by signing a free agent, or two (i can’t remember how many). i wish the preds could get a away with that.
"It's gonna be fun on the bun."
Blocked Shots
Good observation, Dirk, on the blocked shots. It seems like they were blocking a lot of shots during the win streak at the beginning of the year. Now, very few. That’s something the entire team needs to focus on. You’re right, O’Brien is getting exposed a lot the past few games. Ryan Suter…we need you.
NY Rangers
There’s a team that is riddled with injuries, plays somewhat similar to us and keeps winning because they block so many shots. Never mind the fact that Lundqvist is an elite goalie, when 30 shots taken never get to him, how much better is he going to be?
I could be wrong, but our losing streak seems to be a direct result of defensive break down. We have one 1st pair and two 3rd pairs (at best). Hopefully, someone will point out that if you’re going to let people skate around uncontested in your zone, at least use your lazy ass to get in the way of the shot. Maybe clear out the screen too while you’re at it?
EASports' NHL 11 doesn't suck; in fact, it's really damn good! Wait, what!?
Go Predators!!!
A few things
I do not want to get a trend started but a few things that I have noticed:
Last season near last in PK – This season near last in PK
Last season near last in PP – This season near last in PP
Last season 6 game losing streak at beginning of season – ummm you do see who we play next right?
Now I sat in the Skate of the Union and heard Trotz and everyone tell us that the special team were going to be the focus this offseason. “It will improve” we were told. We were told that they were going to tear it all the way down and rebuild it. I do not see any difference.
If Ryan Suter is the cog that holds this team together then maybe we need to work on his contract before Shea’s. Just a thought.
On your last sentence...
Probably work on those in tandem… I think we’d suck just as much with Shea out and Ryan in. Hard to lose a 25+ min. TOI guy…
EASports' NHL 11 doesn't suck; in fact, it's really damn good! Wait, what!?
Go Predators!!!
Yeah
You are right. Need to change that. What I should have said is if Ryan is the cog that holds the team together then we need to work on his right now along with Shea’s contract. We do not need to wait till next year.
The good stuff.
O’Reilly: I mean, wow. This kid is looking great now. Injuries are always bad, but it definitely separates the men from the boys.
EASports' NHL 11 doesn't suck; in fact, it's really damn good! Wait, what!?
Go Predators!!!
Before the Blues on Thursday
I hope that the team can figure out a way for better coverage – the D coverage last night sucked. I also hope they finally learned that every second counts, and they can lose a game in the last few seconds (didn’t they figure this out from last Post season ??) Seems that a few of the guys on ice already told themselves that the game was going into overtime. The passes for the most part were sloppy, and it seemed all too often in the last few games, that attackers coming into the Pred’s zone just skated through. I keep telling myself it’s still early in the season, but that statement will only remain true for so long …
Couple of thoughts
-Someone’s idea of the “bag skate” Tuesday sounds like a good idea.
-Has Trotz put the handcuffs on Belak or has all the food in the press box fried his brain to the fact that he dresses to fight?
-SK74 gets scratched. Huh? The guy was one of the better forwards on the ice Sat. JP should have been scratched.
-Why not split up Weber and Cube? Weber/Klein and Cube/Sulzer would allow SOB to go back to 3rd pairing.
-Cooper brought up a great point. Franson created several scoring chances and yet his TOI was tiny.
-Dirk, I gotta disagree I thought Goc/Wilson/Ward had some nice opportunities.
My frustration lies with how this team is being ran. So SK is starting to step up and we scratch him for Belak, only for Belak to just play about 2 min. ??? So we were actually playing short a forward. I see no rationality behind this. Isn’t that what we have SOB for and Toots from time to time is security? I am still baffled by us calling Klasen up and then not playing him but a few seconds.
I mean some of the decisions have me thinking that Trotz it channeling Les Miles.
The Les Miles comment was funny...
…but Trotz isn’t anymore. He needs to go. Many (if not most) of the games we’re losing are because of pitiful special teams. If its not Trotz, then Trotz HAS to get rid of either or both of the assistants that are in charge of special teams. And if he’s too dumb to do this, then HE oughta be fired.
We have skill on the team, but Trotz turns them all into muckers and grinders cause that’s all he wants EVERYBODY to play…muck and grind. And the points about Belak and Klasen and Kostitsyn make perfect sense. They don’t muck and grind enough, so they’re outta here!
I thought Suter was important, but I had no idea Weber would turtle like he has with Suter gone.
by Pekka for Predator Pontiff on Nov 8, 2010 1:32 PM EST up reply actions
Agree
I have been a FST holder for 4 years now. And the team I see now seems to be the same team that I watched 4 years ago, with the same problems. If Trotz wants to stand solidly behind his assistant coaches then he needs to be treated the same way that they do. The assistant coaches run our special teams and what is one of our biggest problems Special Teams! I am not seeing where the progress is being made. Am I missing something???
Kudos to O’Reilly for his best game of the season. He showed his all around game. We are loosing in many ways now. It shows that we can’t win unless we get stellar goaltending. Which is difficult. Why Sk was scratched? If Dumont can’t do better than the 4th line or if that what Trotz sees from him then why not try to trade him. The team needs to get Wilson going he is very important. Is Legwand trend of last year continuing where he goes into long draughts of not scoring. We need Suter back of course but he won’t solve all the defensive woes
belak
He will probably always be dressed for a ducks game. They have too many players that take liberties with opponents. Simply having Belak dressed keeps them in check more than if he were scratched. I would wait till the blues game to see who plays before getting too riled up over it.
"It's gonna be fun on the bun."
by flyalder on Nov 8, 2010 2:00 PM EST via mobile reply actions
My frustrations aren’t that Belak was dressed. I agree he has to be dressed against the Ducks (and probably the Blues). My problem is that SK finally gets going and he sits. What has JP done? Trotz giving the vet the benefit of the doubt and scratching the youngster. Same thing year after year.
Meanwhile Sully and Legwand have sucked it up over last year and this and they NEVER get "disciplined" like JP and the others do.
And how long did it take for Trotz to split up Klein and Hamhuis lasst year?
He’s an expansion team coach…time for us to step it up and get somebody who can take the Preds to the next level….which is winning a round in the playoffs.
by Pekka for Predator Pontiff on Nov 8, 2010 2:24 PM EST up reply actions
So if we dress Belak for the Blues game then he will play 1:45 again and that will leave us a forward down again!! I mean even when he plays it looks as if Trotz has him on such a short leash that even if the other team takes liberties he still doesn’t do anything.
I agree...
…if you’re gonna put Belak in the lineup, then at least play him in somewhat regular shifts. Maybe 7-9 minutes a game…hell, he can’t do worse in his own zone than a lot of guys are doing right now.
I wonder when Trotz is gonna start booting guys down to Milwaukee like he did last year? Maybe we can lose another Peverley to waivers? He mucked and grinded which led to 7 pts in 37 games with the Preds last year, and now he’s a top line C in Atlanta scoring 60+ pts. System needs a revamping…
by Pekka for Predator Pontiff on Nov 8, 2010 2:39 PM EST up reply actions
Right or wrong
I assume Belak dresses against the Blues because Trotz has SOB and Toots in significant roles right now and neither can afford to sit in the box for 5 mins or worse get the dreaded 5 and 10.
But I agree playing him less than 2 mins on the 2nd night of a back to back is crazy. Pete and Crispy both said it looked like the gas tank was empty with less than 5 to go in the 3rd last night. Belak could have helped that at least a little but Trotz left him catching splinters sliding back and forth on the bench.
I have a feeling Tootoo is gonna be a brawler in Thursday cause of his hit on Colaiacovo and then he turned around and knocked out some other dude that wanted to fight him.
That’s must see TV.
by Pekka for Predator Pontiff on Nov 8, 2010 2:57 PM EST up reply actions
New Game
Anybody want to share their ranking of the 13 current forwards? Base it on all aspects of the game (offense, defense, specialties, intangibles)
Here's my list...
1. O’Reilly
2. Hornqvist
3. Goc
4. Sully
5. Ward
6. Leggy
7. Wilson (as of right now)
8. Tootoo
9. Smithson
10. SK
11. Erat
12. Dumont
13. Belak
by HardCorePredFan316 on Nov 8, 2010 2:52 PM EST up reply actions
My bad
I typed 13 so it made you leave off Spaling. Not many arguments from me but I’m not sure I don’t put Wilson and Toots in front of Legs.
Yeah..
Toots should be higher, just haven’t seen much over the last two games from him. Leggy is struggling bad right now. I wish he could keep up his pace for an entire year like he did during the playoffs last year. Ugh. Losing sucks, and winning cures alot of ills.
by HardCorePredFan316 on Nov 8, 2010 3:50 PM EST up reply actions
I’ll go:
HornQ
O’Reilly
Tootoo (can’t argue with his results given the limited playing time)
Goc
Dumont (makes things happen but Trotz hates him)
Wilson
Legwand (hot start, nothing since…shut down center? who exactly has he shut down?)
Sully (can’t finish last year or this year…should have 70 pts based on his opportunities)
Spaling
SK (shows the odd flash)
Ward (has done nothing so far…penalty killer? nice penalty kill)
Smithson
Erat (completely insignificant)
Belak
Lombardi (who?)
by Pekka for Predator Pontiff on Nov 8, 2010 3:02 PM EST reply actions
SK was scratched because...
He missed a team meeting. You miss a meeting, you sit. Happened to Kovalchuk in NJ this season and happens in every respectable locker room across the league.
I don’t care about his history or why he missed the meeting. Facts are he broke a team rule and Trotz punished him for it. Unlike with Fisher/Britt, it’s over and done with. Case closed. If it happens again, then he’s got bigger issues to worry about than the fans because this organization doesn’t tolerate players that can’t follow team rules…
Predators Hockey: Live it, Love it...
Follow me on Twitter: @SLakePreds
by Seth Lake on Nov 8, 2010 3:38 PM EST via mobile reply actions
I was told...
That Tom Callahan said it during last night’s pregame show on 102.9 FM. It was posted in the GDT at HFBoards.com.
Predators Hockey: Live it, Love it...
Follow me on Twitter: @SLakePreds
by Seth Lake on Nov 8, 2010 6:29 PM EST via mobile up reply actions
Thanks Seth
I didn’t see it anywhere at the time. I appreciate you clearing that up. Along with some of the others on here it’s going to really disappoint me if he starts screwing up. I hope there was a very valid reason as he seems to have great talent and potential. However rules are rules.
Hmm...
I was happier when I thought it was just Trotz putting a brawler in his place for Anaheim. I like the direction SK is going on the ice, I’’ll be very irritated if he screws up off the ice.
EASports' NHL 11 doesn't suck; in fact, it's really damn good! Wait, what!?
Go Predators!!!
That still doesn't explain why he's only averaging 11 minutes on the ice per game...especially when he's scoring while playing with hacks like Smithson and Spaling and Tootoo.
But hey, we don’t need the goals from a guy like that…we’re just unlucky!
by Pekka for Predator Pontiff on Nov 8, 2010 7:11 PM EST up reply actions
An average...
Would count all games played this season, which in turn would be artifically low due to his broken toe. Since his toe has healed, his production and his ice time has been rising accordingly.
I don’t buy this argument, but I’ve seen it here, on Twitter, and at HF. As he’s gotten healthy, he’s contributed more and been rewarded with more ice time. Can’t look at season averages in this case…
Predators Hockey: Live it, Love it...
Follow me on Twitter: @SLakePreds
by Seth Lake on Nov 8, 2010 7:23 PM EST via mobile up reply actions
I'm looking at his last 5 or 6 games only
by Pekka for Predator Pontiff on Nov 8, 2010 7:25 PM EST up reply actions
What is his season total?
Judging by the fact he’s getting limited PP and PK time, 11 minutes isn’t that bad for a 3rd line player…
Predators Hockey: Live it, Love it...
Follow me on Twitter: @SLakePreds
by Seth Lake on Nov 8, 2010 7:42 PM EST via mobile up reply actions
10:52 per game...dead last...except for Belak and Klasen
That’s the point though! He’s the only one that shows potential DESPITE the fact thta he’s playing with hacks game in and game out. Trotz is trying to break him like a horse needs breakin’.
by Pekka for Predator Pontiff on Nov 8, 2010 8:36 PM EST up reply actions
My thoughts on SK...
As I said earlier, I don’t care why he missed the meeting. Fact is that he did and obviously it wasn’t an excused absence so the bottom line is that he failed to live up to his professional obligations. Trotz would be interested in a reason why so that he can weigh that going forward, but for our purposes missing one meeting doesn’t equal anything than a player making a mistake.
I’ve also said I don’t care about his history and I stand by that. Every time a player is acquired via trade, signing, waivers, draft, etc the team does their homework on the player both on and off the ice and makes a determination that the player is worthy to wear the uniform. You store away that info, but the bottom line is you give the player a clean slate and tell them that it’s up to them to keep it clean. This is obviously a black mark on his slate, but by punishing him Trotz reduced it to a smudge.
Obviously, due to SK’s history, Trotz won’t let the slate get dark with smudge after smudge, but a single smudge is just that and it fades over time. One incident does not make a pattern, nor should it be enough to bury a player. Obviously we’ll see if SK is back in the lineup and/or doing extra work tomorrow (scratches from previous game usually do extra skating for conditioning purposes at next practice), but as soon as Trotz is satisfied, I’m satisfied.
The Fisher/Britt ongoing episode IMO is simply not the way to do things. You don’t mete out a punishment a quarter at a time then go on saying further discipline might be forthcoming. You get it done like Trotz did and move beyond the incident.
Predators Hockey: Live it, Love it...
Follow me on Twitter: @SLakePreds
by Seth Lake on Nov 8, 2010 7:40 PM EST via mobile reply actions
Well said
But frankly this isn’t about Kostitsyn. It’s about Trotz’s coaching philosophy. He makes some of the dumbest personnel decisions I’ve ever seen. He benches Dumont…a guy that has scored 70+ pts for us…and moves him down to 4th line duty. Not like we could use those points though…goals are like water…he’s more effective playing 12 minutes than 20 minutes…Beeswax! But as bad as Erat and Sullivan were at times, or as lazy as Arnott Legwand were last year he NEVER benched them…not once. Instead he kept Colin Wilson on the 3rd or 4th line til he earned his keep with one of the top lines with 10 games left to go. And HornQ spent a hell of a lot of time on the 3rd and 4th lines too before he couldn’t be denied. And how about Peverley? How did he go from being a 7pts in 37-odd games player with us to being a 60-70 pt player? Its cause these guys got talent, but TROTZ IS TOO DAMN DUMB TO CHANGE THE SYSTEM TO FIT THE PLAYERS! How long were Hamhuis and Klein kept together? And they were AWFUL! But he would NOT split them apart. How bad is the penalty kill? How bad is the power play? We suck all the way around and most of it has to do with coaching…from Trotz all the way down to the assistants. You know, I’m a season ticket holder and I cheer as loud as anybody, but I’m sick of this crap. We just started to get the attendance up and now we’re gonna mess it all up cause our coach is non-adjustable. I don’t even care about Trotz either…I want HIM (not God, Trotz) to make smart decisions, and if he can’t then he oughta get the boot so somebody who can adjust to the game a little can give it a shot.
I’m pissed and sick of this mediocrity. I know that the season is full of ups and downs. But when the coach’s inflexibility contributes to the downs, that’s when I gotta say something. Early season coaching SNAFUs like this contribute to us finishing 7th in the conference every year so we can get an early April kick in the a$$, and I"m calling them out on it.
by Pekka for Predator Pontiff on Nov 8, 2010 8:56 PM EST up reply actions
Do you not remember the horrendous things Dumont was doing to earn the demotion? I can’t count how many times last year i saw him choose to pass the puck instead of skate 3 strides to get out of the Dzone, only to have it result in a Dzone giveaway in the slot. there is no point in scoring 70 points if you give up 71 goals against. As for the other players you mention, well… Dumont was the easiest replaceable. Arnott was our best offensive center, with nobody on the team capable of filling his shoes. Legwand, while not producing, was still performing his number one job, shutting down the other teams top line every night (a very valuable job), allowing other players to keep easier shifts to try to produce. BTW keeping Klien and Hamhuis together last year prepared Klien for his role this year, thank goodness Trotz has more foresight than most fans.
Trotz has his young guys play the lower lines for a reason. It acclimates them to the NHL game while not asking much of them other than to not be a liability, and then to improve from there. It slows progress but pays off in the long run when those players are more sound defensively to add to their offensive talents. Peverly was too lazy to follow Trotz’s path, and watching his defensive game proves it.
Low PP and PK can be almost completely summed up in one word: SUTER. right now we are missing the “quarterback” for both the PP and PK.
Coaches who adjust to the game are never that successful. When coaches change their system the players are left confused and trying to learn the new way while getting their butts kicked by teams that know what to do.
I don’t understand calling for the coaches head while the team is struggling to recover from horrible injuries to the most important players. injuries are most damaging this early in the season. everyone knows their game and what they have to do to help the team. then they are asked to play a role they don’t have much or any experience with, where as over the season they might play the role once or twice for a few minutes and pick it up a little at a time.
Wait until the team is healthy before rolling in the “Fire Trotz” bus. Because if you look at the record from this season, the team is great, when healthy.
"It's gonna be fun on the bun."
Yeah, a slump buster! LOL!
Maybe even the Chicago game Saturday would be even better?
by Pekka for Predator Pontiff on Nov 9, 2010 12:22 PM EST up reply actions
Flyalder
I’ve read your posts before, and you’re a knowledgeable hockey fan with good ideas and a healthy love for the Preds.
But you’re a lamb being led to slaughter. And you’re blindly following a dude who has never been anything but mediocre. To address your comments:
Dumont does have a problem passing too much, and he may have given up a couple of opportunities in the defensive zone…but don’t exaggerate to make your point…it wasn’t to the tune of 71 goals…and Dumont was a +8 last year which was good for 4th on the team. You’re wrong about that point. The biggest point about Dumont, is that Trotz wants him to be a mucker and grinder, which he IS NOT! But instead of being creative and finding a way to use Dumont’s skills, he sits him on the bench. Because Trotz is too inflexible.
Arnott was our best offensive center? He scored 19 goals last year and was by far our laziest player on the team…by far! If you watched the games last year, you can’t deny this. Furthermore, he was called a cancer in the locker room…all the more reason to bench him, But not Trotz cause he’s too inflexible. I can give Legwand somewhat of a pass cause of his checking role…but he did only score 11 goals last year which is not up to anybody’s standard…except for yours. Spaling could’ve done that job just as well, but we’ll never know cause Trotz is too inflexible to try something like that. And keeping Klein and Hamhuis together prepared Klein for this year? How does being -13 help anyone to do anything but lose games? Oh and remember the Datsyuk play? Far worse than any five bad plays Dumont ever made coming out of the defensive zone, and in fact I’ll cut you a pass because you were probably talking about him rather than Dumont. If Klein doesn’t have Frankie the Bull to babysit him he’s worthless…but Trotz and Poile wouldn’t wanna look stupid with that $1.3 million per that they’re paying him.
Trotz has his young guys playing on lower lines for a reason? To acclimate them? Like how Matt Duchene and Stamkos needed acclimating? Like how Jeff Skinner needs acclimating? He does it to turn them into muckers and grinders. Defense first, and forget about the offensive…to break the spirit. It pays off in the long run? Give me an example of who it has paid off with? Who is an offensive talent we’ve had that’s been allowed to score? Exactly, and that’s why Radulov bolted for the USSR. Peverley doesn’t play defense? That’s all he did here and now he’s one of the better penalty killers for Atlanta. Yeah, with 7 pts in 37-odd games all he did was play offense, right? That was a colossal blunder by the management.
Low PP and PK can be almost completely summed up in one word: SUTER.
Really? Then how come BOTH our PP and PK were at the bottom of the league last year when Suter played all 82 games? Maybe it’s cause Trotz puts Joel Ward on the PP instead of Colin Wilson? No way right? Yeah, I guess Colin is paying his dues which will “pay off in the long run” right?
I do think that injuries have hurt us this year. But one would think that at least the coach would maybe do something intelligent to try and put his finger in the dyke, right? But Trotz is too inflexible. He was last year and the year before and always will be. He will never get us to the next round…cause we’ll never have anything more than a buncha muckersa dn grinders around here. And in the playoffs, everybody becomes a mucker and grinder which is why it’d be a good idea to improve “other areas of our game”.
by Pekka for Predator Pontiff on Nov 9, 2010 12:16 PM EST reply actions
ok first i was thinking of dumont giving away the puck in the dzone last year. i remember Dumont doing that a lot, and generally being very lazy on defense. Klien is middle of the pack in +/- this year and that isn’t bad for the Dman you’re asking to shut down the top lines every night. Arnott was lazy last year and a cancer, and had more points than any other center. specifically, 8 more than legwand who was too valuable to defense to move to the top line, and 16 more points than Goc. We had nobody who could fill his role on the top line.
Don’t use Peverly as the only example of a offensive talent flourishing with another team. every team has had at least one player leave them and become much more successful (and you can attribute his being “one of the better penalty killers for Atlanta” to trotz, cause he wasn’t drafted with that ability) . Radulov bolted for the money, he wasn’t asked to do much more defensively than to just not be a giant liability. Stamkos didn’t need time to acclimate to the NHL? He scored 51 goals his first season? Don’t references elite level prospect to ours. our best is wilson and he is being given every opportunity to develop his offensive game before his defensive (and a prime example of the flexibility you are asking for). And you wanted at least one reference to a player who has developed higher playing abilities on both ends of the ice in trotz’s system right? well: Scott Hartnell, went through the preds system and is now a key offensive and defensive player for the Flyers, and a big part of their cup run.
PP and PK. remember Wilson didn’t joint the team until late last year and was given PP chances. but Ward knew better what other guys on the ice would do and generally had more experience than WIlson. Our PP was on a good pace before injuries started pilling up so i am still inclined to wait and see what happens there. PK, i don’t really know what’s going on there, besides maybe the goaltending.
Do you see Hornqvist, O’reilly, WIlson, being asked to do more Defensively to sacrifice their Offensive game? O’reilly sometimes, but that is due to our lack of centers and he has the ability to do some defense. Every Player isn’t asked to be muckers and grinders. They are asked to simply not be a giant liability and to just be responsible for their part of the team defensive game.
If trotz fails to get the team past the first round of the playoffs, unless we lose to the eventual cup winners again, then i will join the “Fire Trotz” bandwagon. But the last two times we were in the playoffs we lost to the teams who went on to prove they were the best in the league for that year. Something i don’t blame Trotz for. I just fear the Trigger may be getting pulled a little early and without enough cause. the last thing i want is for Trotz to be let go so he can go over to Columbus and we take their place as worst in the division.
"It's gonna be fun on the bun."
I'ma try and limit the length of this one...LOL!
1. Klein is better this year, but not exactly “good”.
2. Peverley didn’t “leave” he was released because he sucked, meaning we got NOTHING for him. And I thought you said he was lazy defensively? But now he’s that good cause of Trotz?
3. Radulov got benched constantly because he “wasn’t playing good enough defensively”.
4. You’re right that maybe Wilson isn’t Stamkos, etc., but is he “being given every opportunity to develop his offensive game?” Right now he’s 17th on the team in total time on ice per game (TOI/G). Just behind the likes of offensive stallwarts like Smithson, Ward and Goc and just ahead of dudes like Dumont, Spaling, Tootoo and Kostitsyn. Note that this (and forthcoming) TOI stats include Lombardi, but per game stats shouldn’t change much when he gets back. He’s 13th on the team in PPTOI/G behind Dumont, Ward and Legwand. They are NOT more skilled than him. For even-strength TOI/G he’s again 17th. Behind Goc, Tootoo and Ward, and just ahead of Smithson. That’s a waste of talent…and don’t forget that he WAS the 7th overall pick, and since then he played 2 years of college and one year in Milwaukee/Nville last year. So he might not be Stamkos, but he’s in his fourth year removed from being an 18 year old draftee so it’s about time to start seeing what he’s got.
5. Forgot about Hartnell…sorry to see him leave. But that’s the only one there is.
6. Wilson has more offensive potential in his left foot than Ward does in his whole body. Don’t get me wrong, I like Ward as a mucker and grinder/PK dude, but he doesn’t belong on the PP over Wilson…ever!
7. They coulda benched Arnott…just like they used to bench Radulov, Wilson and Kostitsyn. Problem is that Trotz doesn’t bench “his favorites” like Sully, Arnott and Legwand…ever. Not even to send a message, no matter how bad they are.
8. I’ma hold you to your last paragraph!
You’re a good fella, and I’m not completely twisted. I just get sick of the crap that gets passed off as great coaching! I appreciate the joust :)
by Pekka for Predator Pontiff on Nov 9, 2010 7:25 PM EST up reply actions
1. Klien is doing a good job in his role from what i’ve seen. agreed not good but adequate and that comes from last years prep work.
2. Peverley didn’t leave on his own, but that wasn’t really my point. every team has had a player leave them, one way or another, and flourish elsewhere ( i don’t really know how else to phrase it to clear it up. pretty much: player no good on team A. go to Team B, player good) i have had limited time watching peverely, so if you think he is good defensively and have seen him more than i will take your word for. but i still remember him sucking at defense here in nashville. Peverley was also a victim of a numbers game. We didn’t get anything for him, but cleared space for O’reilly and WIlson.
3. not playing goo enough defensively easily translates to " He is a giant liability every time his skate touches the ice, and one the team can’t afford
4. WIlson has bee jumping lines waiting for Lombardi or Goc to come back. through this time we had basically one real scoring line (sully-o’rielly-hornqvist) and breaking them up would have been bad. now that Goc has returned i bet WIlson sees his time jump a bit. The others are not more skilled then him, but more experienced. What i’ve seen of wilson on the pp line he looks a little lost and confused. He hasn’t been that great on the PP time he has had to warrant being given more time in games. We will see much more of him when Trotz gets his first line back. the first line was supposed to be Erat-Lomba-Wilson. not much to do when 2/3 is injured and the team is only paying with 1/2 the centers it started with.
5. Hartnell may be the only talent to succeed in trotz’s system, but you only cited one player to fail (Pev.) that’s the problem with a young system and team. it takes time to truly evaluate these things.
6. for your 6 see parts of my 4
7. i really don’t see how benching Arnott was very feasible. wingers we have an abundance of, but not centers. and why bench Sully, he only tied for the lead on the team for points, and was freshly back from the long injury.
8. remember we have to lose to a team in the 1st round, that doesn’t end up winning it all. no shame in losing to the best after all.
i feel ya. not all of trotz’s moves are pure brilliance, but he is still a good/great coach. One who would instantly improve any team he would go to if let go by the preds. this has been a fun discussion.
"It's gonna be fun on the bun."

by 


























