Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: The Most Dangerous Division in Sports

How much are sports writers supposed to buy into the team's culture?

One of the stories burning up the airwaves today centers on Renee Gork, an Arkansas radio reporter who was fired after committing the unpardonable sin of wearing a Florida Gators hat to a press conference featuring Arkansas Razorbacks coach Bobby Petrino. There may or may not be other circumstances which led to her firing, but here's the key moment in the story:

Petrino commented on Gork's choice of headwear after answering a question she asked.

"And that will be the last question I answer with that hat on," Petrino said.

While there's debate about whether or not Ms. Gork should have been fired, and whether there were other extenuating issues surrounding this, Petrino's shut-down reaction to being confronted with a Gator hat fascinates me.

The question here is, to what extent are sports reporters supposed to buy into the culture of the teams they cover? Should they jump on board (or provoke reaction, as Gork may have done), or stay out of it entirely? Is it proper for a coach to shut down questions from someone simply because they're wearing a rival's logo?

Follow after the jump as we look at how this works in the NHL...

Star-divide

This issue is particularly relevant today, with an article running about the pioneering work that Eric McErlain did with the Washington Capitals to establish guidelines for credentialing bloggers with media-style access to the team. In that instance, the concern is the opposite of the Gork-Arkansas case. Most bloggers are unabashed supporters of the teams they cover, and the direction there is basically to not cheer on press row, dress professionally, and don't ask for autographs from the players.

There is one aspect of NHL culture that closely parallels the Arkansas situation, however. In an effort to support respect for the team, many NHL franchises have gigantic logos in the middle of the dressing room, and forbid visitors from daring to tread upon it. SI's Michael Farber wrote about it in Ottawa, and a Minnesota reporter ran afoul of this practice in Pittsburgh.

Last season, I myself wandered into the Nashville Predators' room after a home game, looked around for someone to interview, and was startled by a hand on my shoulder, pulling me back.

"Watch out, don't step on the logo," a PR rep told me.

"If it's so sacred, what's it doing on the floor?" was my reply.

If the team logo is such a hallowed image, then why is it taking up most of the available space in the locker room? I certainly don't ever recall seeing the American flag portrayed in such a fashion.

Most importantly, to what extent am I, or an actual trained journalist, supposed to care about team traditions like this in order to do the job we're there for? After a big game when you're trying to work your way around a crowded room, why are grown adults playing the old "step on a crack, break your mother's back" routine? Does a team's enforcement of such traditions establish a tone with the working media that ultimately skews objectivity and blunts criticism?

I'd say so.

Comment 15 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

The San Jose Sharks have solved the floor logo issue by having a form fitting carpet that gently covers the big shark when the bustling press corp enters the room. Seems like an adequate solution to the “problem.”

by Preds On The Glass on Aug 17, 2010 1:11 PM EDT reply actions  

Another question, in light of our ongoing ladies hockey apparel discussion, I wonder if it was a ladies hat that she was wearing or if a ladies version was even available.

by Preds On The Glass on Aug 17, 2010 1:16 PM EDT reply actions  

"Buy in" not the issue

The issue here is more akin to reporters wearing any sports team logo gear in the locker room. I’ve heard many say (and I agree) it is inappropriate for a reporter to wear a jersey into a locker room, home team or away. Same issue here. It’s basically waiving a flag saying either “I’m a fan, don’t take me seriously” at best or “I’m a fan of the enemy and going to try to trip you up” at worst. Just inappropriate and definitely worth dismissal for a professional (not just a blogger) to show up wearing any gear. The coach was completely reasonable to not answer another question from someone wearing the hat of any team, especially a rival. He was generous to answer one.

Now – the issue of reporters “buying in” to a team system is a legit issue – I think that was always a challenge for John Glennon covering the Preds: he bought what he was sold. But that isn’t the issue here, I don’t think.

Blog- http://nicholsonrecords.com/paul
Hockey Pics- http://flickr.com/photos/paulnich/collections/72157600076075216/
Hockey Vids- http://vimeo.com/pwnicholson/videos/tag:nhl

by pwnicholson on Aug 17, 2010 1:20 PM EDT reply actions  

I agree that wearing any team paraphernalia is unprofessional. I don’t think anyone should be fired for wearing enemy gear into a locker room, but it shows an incredible lack of common courtesy and respect. While I wouldn’t have fired that reporter, I might have shown her the door and issued directions to Urban Meyer’s office.

I also think that you do need to respect team traditions or ‘buy in’ as you put it simply because you are a guest in their house. To me it’s the same as having friends over. They need to respect the rules of my house, and when I’m in their house, I need to reciprocate. It’s the same in sports. If you’re going to their locker room, you need to abide by their culture. It’s not like there’s an immense burden being placed on the media by asking them to do so.

by Predaceous on Aug 17, 2010 1:37 PM EDT up reply actions  

"buy in" definition

I guess it’s a different type of “buy in” I was talking about. Sure, you need to obey the house rules unless they are things like “never question the goalies performance”. I was saying reporters shouldn’t “buy in” too much as far as the team philosophy (in the Preds case: no one ever really questions if “the Predator Way” is a way that could ever have success or is doomed to mediocrity.)

Blog- http://nicholsonrecords.com/paul
Hockey Pics- http://flickr.com/photos/paulnich/collections/72157600076075216/
Hockey Vids- http://vimeo.com/pwnicholson/videos/tag:nhl

by pwnicholson on Aug 17, 2010 1:54 PM EDT up reply actions  

Well, in fairness...

I know I’ve questioned it (team philosophy, etc) often enough in my blogs and I believe that I’ve seen similar questions from most of the Predators bloggers (including Dirk) in their writing efforts.

Now, I don’t know that I’ve seen too many times where those questions were put directly towards a coach, player, GM, etc. by any of us (that said, I’ve only seen a significant number of interview questions answered in Brandon’s post game blogs).

David Singleton w/ HockeyIndependent

by David Singleton on Aug 17, 2010 1:58 PM EDT up reply actions  

A question

Can you point to any concrete examples where you think a blogger or reporter’s objectivity has been compromised?

by emcerlain on Aug 17, 2010 5:13 PM EDT reply actions  

When it comes to the “team tradition” angle, nothing to the extreme like in this Arkansas case, no. It’s more of a nuisance here in Nashville, although I can imagine in some cities where the locker room is more crowded after a game, it can be a real hindrance.

In the NHL, objectivity is more often influenced by the giving or revoking of access to the team. That’s a card that can get played in just about any sport, however.

On the Forecheck is SB Nation's blog covering the Nashville Predators. Catch me on Twitter at @Forechecker.

by Dirk Hoag on Aug 17, 2010 9:44 PM EDT up reply actions  

Just an aside

Here in DC, the problem solved itself. Here’s what happened to me after the last game of the 2006-07 regular season:

http://offwing.com/2007/05/on-the-caps-logo

As it turned out, the problem solved itself. The next season, the Caps revamped their uniforms, but the new logo wasn’t embroidered into the locker room carpet. Instead, when we got back for the start of the next season, the logo was completely covered by fabric.

by emcerlain on Aug 18, 2010 9:56 AM EDT up reply actions  

Now THAT is funny...

The old “golden rule”.

He who has the gold, makes the rules.

On the Forecheck is SB Nation's blog covering the Nashville Predators. Catch me on Twitter at @Forechecker.

by Dirk Hoag on Aug 18, 2010 10:33 AM EDT up reply actions  

Stepping on the team logo

It sounds like a Curb Your Enthusiasm episode. Larry would definitely step on it

by Lil cutie on Aug 17, 2010 5:50 PM EDT reply actions  

John Glennon

My experience with John was always positive. In between periods, he was more than happy to talk shop and share his opinions with the average fans. He wasn’t afraid to present unvarnished critiques of how he thought the game, or the season, was progressing. He did not scurry off to the press room to hobknob with the Preds organization folks. He seemed a fan of hockey, not just sports, and I will miss his coverage greatly. He was the best reporter the Tennessean has had covering the Preds. I hear he has been assigned to cover some other team here in town.
You know, J.R. Lind is a huge hockey fan…

by cisar on Aug 17, 2010 6:08 PM EDT reply actions  

It is not good that we’ve lost the thoughtful Preds coverage that John provided. He was a great source of current info, no doubt.

If I was a conspiracy nut, I’d say it was another attempt by the Wrap to poke the Preds (and the team’s fans) squarely in the eye. I just can’t say enough bad about that joke of a paper. It’s too bad we’ve lost John because he was one of the few bright spots there. And, as you said, he was a genuinely nice guy – as down to earth as they come. He would talk to anyone.

Wonder if he’s going to continue with his reporting for THN?

by blueline on Aug 17, 2010 7:34 PM EDT up reply actions  

John was great, no question about it. Very approachable and friendly.

On the Forecheck is SB Nation's blog covering the Nashville Predators. Catch me on Twitter at @Forechecker.

by Dirk Hoag on Aug 17, 2010 9:37 PM EDT up reply actions  

A member of the media....

A member of the media is to be impartial at all press conferences. Isn’t that taught in Journalism 101. This young lady probably didn’t deserve to be fired but moved to cover local pee wee football for a few weeks to learn her lesson on being a professional reporter. No team logos on hats shirts etc. I do not believe the press needs to “buy in” with the team. Your response DIrk to the PR Guy on the logo on the floor would have been mine too. You are there to do a job and not play hop scotch over the logo. If the logo is that important then all interviews need to be done in the press room and not the locker room.

by jmkiii58 on Aug 18, 2010 8:26 AM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Nashville Predators.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Stax_at_night_small
Strictly for imagination. Battle of team goal chants
Small
So apparently Suter is 86 out the door
Josiah_small
My Roster Proposal for the Predators...Give Me Yours
Small
Whats the cost for the "Big-2"
Gameon100_small
Miss: A Recurring Theme
Preds_game_small
Moving on from Game 4
Sackboy_small
Why are the Preds so streaky?
Preds_game_small
What was gained, or lost, in Game 4
Predhead_small
Intent to Blow
E-pred_small
We're all talkin about it. Let's make it official.....

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Best of Nashville 2011 - Best Sports Blog

About OTF

is the Forechecker, churner of NHL stats & analysis, and managing editor of On the Forecheck.

Me_medium_medium

Got a question, a suggestion, or are interested in advertising here to reach thousands of Nashville Predators fans? Feel free to email the.forechecker@gmail.com.

Are you new here? Read this first!

On The Forecheck Community Guideilnes

Check us out on iTunes!

Otf_podcast_medium


Managers

Forechecker_35_small Dirk Hoag

Muckers

Rad_small Chris Burton

Grinders

Kanye_pekka_small Sam Page

91490_obit_heimerdinger_football_small Aditya T (smashville)

Adslogo_small Ryan B. Miller

209353_10150193095230917_581960916_8380447_5205638_o_small Marc Torrence

Enforcers

Infinite_sadness_avatar_small 3DLink

Photo_on_2011-12-09_at_00 davisca