2010-11 Nashville Predators Report Card: Kevin Klein
With the season now over, it's time to take a look back and examine each player's individual performance. We'll briefly break it down, and then offer a letter grade for the year. It's report cards, Nashville Predators-style, from Blum to Wilson. Next up: Kevin Klein.
The Skinny: With a new 3-year, $4.05 million contract, Kevin Klein grew into a slightly larger role as one of the more senior defenseman on the Predators. Having been drafted 12 spots ahead of Shea Weber there are always some expectations in the background that perhaps KK should produce more offensively, but I think we can safely say that we know what we've got in Klein; a defensive blueliner who can face tough matchups and do well on the penalty kill.
The downside of this situation for Klein is that by the nature of his job, he's going to end up on the wrong side of a lot of highlights, scooping the puck out of his own net a lot more often than celebrating a goal of his own. Particularly with #8, so many of these highlights seem to point out a poor decision which leads to the score, like getting lured out of position by an opponent along the boards, or a communication mix-up which leaves a man wide open in front. That leads to a polarizing of opinion on Klein among the fan base, as many want to see him shipped out of town ASAP, while others take that workload into account.
Basically, the expectations for a guy like Klein are to hold down the fort under trying circumstances, and accept the fact that he'll hear the boos more often than the cheers for his efforts.
The Performance: He led the Preds in PK ice time per game, and helped the team rebound into becoming one of the top penalty killing squads once again. Yes, in 5-on-5 play the shots tilted against Nashville during Klein's ice time, but that's partially excused by the teammates he usually worked with (let's face it, he didn't have a Suter or Weber alongside him). On the offensive end, he did take a step forward by firing about 50% more shots on net than last season, but he's still doesn't show more than flashes of effectiveness there.
One under-appreciated aspect of Klein's game is that he does his job without taking very many penalties. Just as he did in 2009-10, he finished the season among the league leaders in fewest penalties taken when you screen for defensemen with at least 40 games played and 10 minutes of 5-on-5 play per game (8th best out of 196). KK took 0.2 penalties per 60 minutes of 5-on-5 play, compared to figures of 1.1 for Shane O`Brien, 1.0 for Ryan Suter, and 0.9 for Shea Weber. And it's not like Klein is particularly soft, either - he can get a bit chippy when the time calls for it.
The Grade: Before the season I pegged him for 3 goals and 15 assists, both of which came out within 1 of being correct. Recognizing the job he was facing, I also expected him to end up with a negative Plus/Minus, so his +9 comes as a pleasant surprise (he got some friendly bounces early on, but rode things out after that reasonably well). In total, I think Klein makes for a good reminder that particularly with hockey, we often need to set aside the forehead-slap-inducing highlight moments and try to consider the overall results, both in what occurred (goals for and against) and what didn't occur (the penalties). In a borderline call, I'm going to give Kleiner a B here, with my only real concern being those shot totals in 5-on-5 (which, granted, is probably the single most important metric for a skater). If he had outperformed offensively, or driven positive results more consistently in 5-on-5, he'd get that A.
24 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I am going to say if this poll ends up with over 200 F’s, its not cause the system was hacked
Canucks new slogan: Show us some hits, we'll show you our tits
Haha. I was thinking the same thing. Hopefully the hacker will stay away so we can get a true measure of OTF viewers’ ratings.
Of the remaining 4 teams in the playoffs, I think many of the 2nd and 3rd D-pairings are worse than Klein. Just watch.
I think he played better toward the end of the season and chewed up a lot of minutes on a highly ranked PK unit. He’s also pretty effective at moving the puck. Because of that, I give him a B-minus.
by Griz-ATL on May 24, 2011 4:24 PM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
Right or Wrong
I will always compare Kleiner to guys like Hamhuis, Zanon, Bouillon, and now Blum. This was another year where I would have loved to have any and all of those guys playing on the shutdown pair over Klein. Therefore not giving him anything above a C-.
You say he can get chippy (and I agree he can’t) but he doesn’t do it enough. I don’t expect him to drop the gloves every night with the Engelland’s of the league, but I do expect him to lay hits on forwards (i.e. Bieksa or D. Murray).
I still maintain that if Cube is healthy and with the emergence of Blum, Klein should be traded to get an offensive forward in town.
Fact
Klein was the swear word I used most this past season
Canucks new slogan: Show us some hits, we'll show you our tits
Thou shalt not taketh smacketh about Predators....
BUT SORRY… Klein’s gotta go. Totally liability every shift he’s on the ice.
You should have counted the number of "Klein-Aways" as part of his evaulation
He made as many tape to tape passes to the other team as he did to his. With that said, I do think he played better than last year. But that could have been Blum picking him up. D+
… the former life of the Webeard…
"The Final Countdown" is now playing in your head. You're welcome.
by Michaeltastic on May 24, 2011 4:28 PM EDT via mobile up reply actions
B-
Klein suffers from the exact same thing almost every other defenseman in the NHL suffers from – he’s not Shea Weber or Ryan Suter.
We’re spoiled, folks. You watch the best defensive pair in the game at work, and it’s a beautiful thing, but that makes it easier to pick up on the rest of the D’s faults. Klein’s on the ice the most after 6/20, so it makes sense that he becomes the scapegoat.
There’s bad, yeah, but you have to take the good with it, and I was pretty pleased with Klein’s body of work this year, particularly in the playoffs. He certainly improved with the addition of Blum, but it’s hard to say who affected who, really.
Lemme quote the late, great Colonel Sanders. He said "I'm too drunk to taste this chicken."
I think B is a good grade. Played a lot of minutes, had a lot of blocked shots, had a good playoffs. He is a pretty good passer and he definitely improved over the course of last year. His +/- improved 22 points from last year. His experience will play dividends next year without Bouillon and O’Brien.
He seems to be learning from his mistakes. He also seems to be watching Suter and carries the puck in the zone when appropriate and recognizes when it is time to jump into the rush and head to the net.
He needs to keep learning and work with whomever he is paired with to more effectively shut down the opposition. His teammates need to learn to stick around so that he has an outlet for passes out of the def zone when the other team is forechecking heavily.
I’m glad Klein will be back next year.
So, my tactic with conservation of apex predators is to get people excited and take them to where they live.
~Steve Irwin
There is no tenderness or humanity in fanaticism.
~Joe Strummer
Solid B
I really thought this was an easy call. He had a C+ performance for the first half of the season and an A- performance for the second half. It averages out and I like how he developed over the year. I hope Klein stays put and I hope as a community we give him a fair shot next year.
EASports' NHL 11 doesn't suck; in fact, it's really damn good! Wait, what!?
Go Predators!!!
B-
I found myself not yelling as much at Klein this season, but he had his moments. Then again, what defenseman doesn’t screw up every now and then? Not everyone is a Suter or Lidstrom. He obviously seemed to play much better when partnered with Blum, so I’m looking forward to seeing how that pairing performs over the course of a full season, provided Trotz keeps them together
I tell people who ask that I'm majoring in Spectator Sports with a minor in Sleep.
C+
Makes for a decent 3rd pairing Dman, IMO. Just doesn’t do enough offensively to allow me to bump him up to the B grade.
by Grizzledbear on May 24, 2011 7:04 PM EDT via mobile reply actions
C-
Forget that he is not shea weber or suter, hes not an average dman. Average Dman dont make nearly as many boneheaded plays as he did this year. I lost count by Febuary how many times i said **** it klein! He gets a C alone for his move in Atlanta when the puck hit him right in the feet and HE STARED AT IT. ATL scores and wins the game. Get rid of him we have ample amount of young better defenseman ready to play.
D-
Maybe even an F. Dont like him on the ice..Has moments but you know what they say about a blind Squirrel. To many OH.S%*! moments. Blum made him look better than he was. Hopefully he is trade bait come 2011 draft day.
D
Solid at times, but when the mistakes come – boy are they epic. Bill Buckner-level. He’s cost us many games, and if this many people’s opinions are that high on him. Time to TRADE TRADE TRADE.
"My, my, here's one for the (no) neck. Don't relax, 'cause you're next for the check!"
I think someone hacked the poll to all ’A’s this time as well. I suspect cisar. ;)
"My, my, here's one for the (no) neck. Don't relax, 'cause you're next for the check!"
D..could have been a C-
As was said..too many Oh S#!% moments. Too streaky for me, would rather have Bouillon back with Blum and trade Klein, get something for him. How I see it:
Weber/Suter
Bouillon/Blum
Franson/Josi(Ellis)
by HardCorePredFan316 on May 25, 2011 11:51 AM EDT reply actions

by 



























