Assessing the Trotz/Poile Era

Obviously, the Era is still ongoing and could feasibly continue for the next 5 years, but by no means is it too early to assess the work our dynamic duo has done for a decade and a half. I will help foster this argument by posting relevant facts and details towards the entirety of the situation. In the end, all that really matters, after 15 years of the longest tenured management combination in Professional Sport History, are you happy with the results? Have you enjoyed this era for better and for worse? 'Til death do you part? Sorry, that just seemed fitting to say.

Relevant Argument One: Off Ice Difficulties

The Predators started as a small market expansion franchise with a roster full of castoffs. It took years to shed that stigma as we finally were able to sign top free agents in 2006. Though in the following years, a number of excellent NHL talent would leave the team in large part due to financial reasons (Timonen, Radulov, Suter). The franchise nearly moved to Hamilton/Kansas City around 2007 due to a lack of corporate support in Nashville and the nefarious "Boots" Del Biaggio. Despite all these distractions, the squad remained competitive for 8 years while developing players from within.

Relevant Argument Two: Regular Season Consistency

2011-12 NHL Nashville Predators* 82 48 26 8 104 .634 0.34 0.01 2nd Lost NHL Conference Semi-Finals B. Trotz (48-26-8)
2010-11 NHL Nashville Predators* 82 44 27 11 99 .604 0.31 0.01 2nd Lost NHL Conference Semi-Finals B. Trotz (44-27-11)
2009-10 NHL Nashville Predators* 82 47 29 6 100 .610 0.06 0.06 3rd Lost NHL Conference Quarter-Finals B. Trotz (47-29-6)
2008-09 NHL Nashville Predators 82 40 34 8 88 .537 -0.19 0.06 5th B. Trotz (40-34-8)
2007-08 NHL Nashville Predators* 82 41 32 9 91 .555 0.13 0.12 2nd Lost NHL Conference Quarter-Finals B. Trotz (41-32-9)
2006-07 NHL Nashville Predators* 82 51 23 8 110 .671 0.78 0.05 2nd Lost NHL Conference Quarter-Finals B. Trotz (51-23-8)
2005-06 NHL Nashville Predators* 82 49 25 8 106 .646 0.32 -0.07 2nd Lost NHL Conference Quarter-Finals B. Trotz (49-25-8)
2003-04 NHL Nashville Predators* 82 38 29 11 4 91 .555 -0.05 -0.04 3rd Lost NHL Conference Quarter-Finals B. Trotz (38-29-11-4)

In an 8 year span, the Nashville Predators enjoyed the 5th most regular season success in the NHL. Only New Jersey, Detroit, Vancouver and San Jose won more games during that period. They earned 7 playoff berths. Few teams in NHL history have enjoyed the such consistency for that long (seriously) and many of them were dynasties that won multiple cups. Obviously we weren't a dynasty nor came close to winning a cup but being able to root for a competitive team for 8 straight years is almost unheard of in Professional Hockey. This franchise would have been in pretty elite company if he hadn't missed the postseason by 3 points in 2009. In 95 years of NHL hockey, only 23 franchises have managed 9 or more postseason berths in a row.

Team Post-season streak Consecutive post-season appearances Stanley Cup Championships during streak
Boston Bruins 29 seasons 1967–68 through to 1995–96 2
Chicago Black Hawks 28 seasons 1969–70 through to 1996–97
St. Louis Blues 25 seasons 1979–80 through to 2003–04
Montreal Canadiens 24 seasons 1970–71 through to 1993–94 8
Detroit Red Wings 22 seasons 1990–91 to present 4
Montreal Canadiens 21 seasons 1948–49 through to 1968–69 10
Detroit Red Wings 20 seasons 1938–39 through to 1957–58 5
Philadelphia Flyers 17 seasons 1972–73 through to 1988–89 2
Atlanta Flames/Calgary Flames 16 seasons 1975–76 through to 1990–91 1
Toronto Maple Leafs 15 seasons 1930–31 through to 1944–45 3
New York Islanders 14 seasons 1974–75 through to 1987–88 4
Washington Capitals 14 seasons 1982–83 through to 1995–96
Edmonton Oilers 13 seasons 1979–805 through to 1991–92 5
New Jersey Devils 13 seasons 1996–97 through to 2009–10 2
Buffalo Sabres 11 seasons 1974–75 through to 1984–85
Pittsburgh Penguins 11 seasons 1990–91 through to 2000–01 2
Philadelphia Flyers 11 seasons 1994–95 through to 2005–06
Nordiques/Colorado Avalanche 11 seasons 1994–95 through to 2005–06 2
Ottawa Senators 11 seasons 1996–97 through to 2007–08
Chicago Black Hawks 10 seasons 1958–59 through to 1967–68 1
New York Rangers 10 seasons 1977–78 through to 1986–87
San Jose Sharks 9 seasons 2002–03 through to 2012–13

Relevant Argument Three: A Lack of Playoff Success

Always a bridesmaid, never a bride. For 8 consecutive years, TP iced competitive teams that earned a playoff berth every year except for one. In those 7 post seasons, 5 times this squad lost in the opening round and twice won a series only to be eliminated in the Conference Semis. At first glance, that appears to be a woeful run of futility. But it's important to consider the nature of our opponents in those series:

04 – DET; '03 SC Champs, 109 point season, P Trophy, +66 GD, Team of vets with depth
06 – SJ; 7 less regular season points than us, +8 less GD, Tremendous squad with depth
07 – SJ; 3 less pts than us, +1 less GD, Elite team that could have easily won the P Trophy.
08 – DET; 115 points, Won Stanley Cup, +73 GD 30 goals better than the 2nd best team.
10 – CHI; 112 points, 2nd best GD at +62, A Team full of Elite players, Won Stanley Cup,
11 – VAN; 117 pts, P Trophy, +77 GD 26 goals better than #2, One win away from the SC
12 – PHX; Phoenix were a solid playoff team with good depth. This series was a failure.

In 6 out 7 series we faced an Elite opponent, squads that employed one or more generational talents and were at least among the 5 best teams in the NHL that year. Additionally those squads were always near or at the cap while we were consistently under by up to 14 - 20 Million.

Relevant Argument Four: The Glass Half Empty

7 Playoff berths in 15 years (46%). Two playoff series wins in 15 years. Zero relevant banners in 15 years.

After 15 year under the reign of Barry Trotz and David Poile, this franchise has a total record of 544-471-60-98.

This FanPost was written by an OTF reader, and does not represent the views of the editorial staff. Got something you'd like to share? <a href="" target="new">Post your own</a>!

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join On the Forecheck

You must be a member of On the Forecheck to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at On the Forecheck. You should read them.

Join On the Forecheck

You must be a member of On the Forecheck to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at On the Forecheck. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.